New Program Takes the Benefits out of Breathalyzer Refusal in DUI Cases


Breathalyzer test refusals have long been a thorn in the side of DUI prosecutors across the country. Although refusal itself carries penalties-in some states even criminal penalties-it is sometimes advantageous for a driver to refuse the test. In particular, in some states repeat offenders regularly avoid harsher penalties by refusing to submit to breathalyzer tests .

While the refusal itself is admissible as evidence in many states, lack of breathalyzer or BAC data leaves an important hole in the prosecution's case, and makes it impossible to file charges under the harsher statutes some states have enacted for drivers with especially high BACs. A skilled DUI attorney, knowing that the state lacks critical evidence, can often win an acquittal at trial.

A pilot program underway in nine South Carolina counties may put an end to the benefits of breathalyzer refusal once and for all. In most areas, when a driver refuses the breathalyzer test, that's the end of the story. He can still be charged with driving under the influence, and still faces penalties associated with the refusal, but no further effort is made to collect BAC data.

Under the pilot program, officers don't stop their investigation with the refusal. Instead, they go to a judge or magistrate and request a warrant for a blood sample. This allows law enforcement to obtain valid blood alcohol content evidence even in the face of a refusal.

Under this system, the possible benefits of refusing the breathalyzer quickly drop away. Drivers who refuse the test may still face penalties for refusal, but will not avoid BAC evidence. In fact, since blood test results are generally considered more reliable, the evidence obtained through a warrant for blood testing is generally offers the fewer options for challenging the validity of the test.

In theory, the process would be more expensive and time consuming for law enforcement, but as drivers become aware that the benefits of refusal are being eliminated, and that they may actually be solidifying the evidence against them, refusals are expected to decline.

Prosecutors in Pitt County, South Carolina, who joined the pilot program last year, have seen that theory bear out. In addition, prosecutors say that with the blood test results in hand, they're seeing fewer DUI trials-DUI defendants who know that the state has blood test data have proven more willing to plead guilty.

» Back to DUI Articles

PAID ATTORNEY ADVERTISEMENT: THIS WEB SITE IS A GROUP ADVERTISEMENT AND THE PARTICIPATING ATTORNEYS ARE INCLUDED BECAUSE THEY PAY AN ADVERTISING FEE. It is not a lawyer referral service or prepaid legal services plan. Total DUI is not a law firm.  Your request for contact will be forwarded to the local lawyer who has paid to advertise in the ZIP code you provide. Total DUI does not endorse or recommend any lawyer or law firm who participates in the network nor does it analyze a person's legal situation when determining which participating lawyers receive a person's inquiry. It does not make any representation and has not made any judgement as to the qualifications, expertise or credentials of any participating lawyer. The information contained herein is not legal advice. No representation is made that the quality of the legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers. Any information you submit to Total DUI does not create an attorney-client relationship and may not be protected by attorney-client privilege. Do not use the form to submit confidential, time-sensitive, or privileged information. All photos are of models and do not depict clients. All case evaluations are performed by participating attorneys. To see the attorney in your area who is responsible for this advertisement, please click here or call 866-200-8052.

FLORIDA ONLY: Total DUI is considered a lawyer referral service in the state of Florida under the Florida Rules of Professional Conduct. By all other standards, Total DUI is a group advertisement and not a lawyer referral service.

If you live in Mississippi, Missouri, New York or Wyoming, please click here for additional information.